Carolyn S Neltner

Performed a discetomy on me in 2009. No issues so far 14 years later.

She paralyzed my mother in 2005, look up the article in the Columbus Dispatch. Please, look for a different doctor. Quote from article: "The cervical discectomy took place on Dec. 1, 2005, in Mount Carmel East hospital. During the procedure, a degenerating disc was removed and a healthy bone plug was to be inserted between the C5 and C6 vertebrae, Eisen said. The plug was to be set in place with a hammer and screws. When placing the plug, Neltner "tamped it in too far and hit Libby's spinal cord," Eisen said. "The jury found that she was negligent in the procedure and negligent in addressing the complications that occurred over the next six to eight hours." She paralyzed my mother in 2005, look up the article in the Columbus Dispatch. Please, look for a different doctor. … More

Dr Neltner performed major surgery on my neck if I had to do it again God forbid I would put my care in her capable hands again

I have tried to contact the office and no one answers. Dr Neltner is a great doctor. I have had neck and back surgeries from her. She is the best.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

My husband had surgery from her and it is wrong. All screws are pulling away from spine. One month later we told her something is wrong and she would not even address it. Another month went by and she finally said to get an MRI. Well than he,needed surgery immediately. My husband said he would get surgery from someone else. All she cares about is the money. She knows. I would not give her a star but had to so I could give a revue My husband had surgery from her and it is wrong. All screws are pulling away from spine. One month later we told her something is wrong and she would not even address it. Another month went by and she finally said to get an MRI. Well than … More

I had lower spinal fusion completed 9 years ago. My husband had cervical fusion 2 years ago. Both of us had great results. No complications. Remember you must follow all aftercare instructions or you will not heal correctly. She’s always been accessible and open with us. We highly recommend her.

Doctor Neltner is professional and friendly. I've had two minor surgeries performed by Doctor Neltner with no problems. Her staff is also very good.

I'm amazed at how comfortable Dr. Neltner makes her patients and their families. Very informative, communicative and professional. I'm stunned at any patients that scored her low. One can only assume they may be difficult patients. This doctor is top notch. I put my life in her hands and she impressed me at every turn.