Eva Toth

Take my advice when I say this, do NOT ever go to her! I was referred to her 3 years ago when a nurse practitioner found a lump on my thyroid which was found to be cancerous. I had a total thyroidectomy & was diagnosed with a disorder of the parathyroid glands that affects my body's ability to absorb calcium. My calcium drops from too much activity &I need to take supplements. At one point my calcium dropped below the normal levels & her solution was to keep upping my calcium dosage. At one point she doubled my dosage & suddenly I started having side effects such as GI upset, muscle & bone aches & horrible headaches. When I called in, her nurses would take a message & then get back to me 2-3 days later. I would ask another question & they would go ask her, & again waited 2-3 days for an answer! If I had an appointment with her & made a complaint she would tell me to see a specialist because it's not her area of concern. Thankfully I'm done with her. I found a much better doctor.

Had a 10:30 appointment was taken back to a room at 12:45!! Do not make an appointment on a day when you have anything else to do(Go to work, pick up your children at school or be home so they aren't locked out of the house when they get off the school bus).

I have been with Dr. Toth for over a decade and her care is extraordinary. She is very knowledgeable and informative. Very much worth the visit.

Dr. Toth is a wonderful doctor very reliable very excellent and demands the respect of her patients. My husband has been her patient for over 30 years.

My appointment was at 11:15 am. Left at 12:21 without seeing the doctor. How does a doctor get an hour and a half behind when they open at 9 and my appointment was at 11.15. No patient should be waiting over 10 minutes for an appointment. And the masking wearing enforcement is unacceptable.

Excellent care! Very understanding.

Dr toth was always rude to me she never really listened to me I was with her for 3 years until I got kicked out for missing appointments only thing she ever pressed was me losing weight diagnosed me with type 2 diabetes I get a new doctor and come to find out I’m type 1 not type 2 and I’m actually receiving help and my numbers are great I wanna know how she still has a license to practice definitely don’t recommend Dr toth was always rude to me she never really listened to me I was with her for 3 years until I got kicked out for missing appointments only thing she ever pressed was me losing weight diagnosed me with type 2 diabetes I get a new doctor … More

Dr. Toth has/is seeing not only myself but my 2 daughters as well. She is very knowledgeable and ensures in her conversations with you, that you understand what the diagnosis is and what the treatment would consist of. Dr. Toth also does not pretend to know areas that are not her expertise--recommends experts in the field that goes beyond her profession--and has her staff arrange the appointments. Dr. Toth is thorough in her examinations and explains the step-by-step plan to better health. And, she is not inclined to prescribe medicines for a quick fix. Her two offices also allow for more appointment times availability and her staff is always courteous and ready to help. Questions asked are answered in a timely fashion. Bottom line: Dr. Toth is very good! Dr. Toth has/is seeing not only myself but my 2 daughters as well. She is very knowledgeable and ensures in her conversations with you, that you understand what the diagnosis is and what the treatment would consist of. Dr. Toth also does … More

Worst doctor ever!!! She doesn't even deserve 1 star. The wait time is awful, they even forgot me in the waiting room once. She asked me why I don't own an iPhone because they are the best and work with the new insulin pumps then told me I should go get one. Excuse me? I don't want one but she kept repeating that. She knows I'm diabetic and in between pcp's right now due to COVID-19 but REFUSES to write me a rx for my meds. She said she doesn't want the "responsibility" of it. I have been a diabetic for over 30 years and have seen more than my share of doctors. She is by far the rudest, most unprofessional person I've ever met. Worst doctor ever!!! She doesn't even deserve 1 star. The wait time is awful, they even forgot me in the waiting room once. She asked me why I don't own an iPhone because they are the best and work with the new insulin pumps then told me I … More

This doctor does not care about you. Just the paycheck you supply. She will leave you to suffer and die. You will have to find a new doctor to even get any help with what she should be treating. Do yourself a favor if you want good treatment. Pick another doctor. I've had over 35 pound weight loss in a month, and much more and they can't even call back for days at a time. Even e.r. visits. They don't care at all. The other doctors can't believe she left me suffering in this hell when obviously needing surgery long ago. This doctor does not care about you. Just the paycheck you supply. She will leave you to suffer and die. You will have to find a new doctor to even get any help with what she should be treating. Do yourself a favor if you want good … More

Dr. Toth has been very kind and caring with me. She is very matter-of-fact, which I appreciate. She spent a good amount of time with me, and my examination was very thorough. Highly recommended!

Find another doctor. She will leave you to die. Just don't be dumb like me and listen to her. I'm going to be lucky to make it to my surgery that needed done months ago and she ignored. Run. Run fast away from this practice.

If I could give her 0 stars I would. One of the worst providers ever! She is very slow. Be prepared to be at her office for 3 - 4 hours! Her staff is very rude and very unorganized.

provider wanted to cut thyroid medicine when labs for free t4 & free t3 were falling. The labs did not correlate to her decision to cut the dosage. I truly question this decision.

Provider decisions are questionable. She wanted to cut my thyroid dosage when the labs clearly showed that the Free T3 & Free T4 were clearly falling. Her bedside manner is rude.

Wait for hours and hours in waiting room.

She lost my entire file, so I had no evidence of treatment by an endocrinologist in court. The office had months to tell me, or come up with a new one, but no, sadly they thought breaking the bad news at the 11th hour was the way to go.

Dr Toth diagnosed me as type 2. I was very sick could hardly keep my eyes open and weighed almost 100 pounds and she blamed it on my diet. I was starting to lose vision and couldn’t stay awake, not even to drive. I finally convince myself to go to the hospital where I was diagnosed with type 1 not 2 at Sharon regional. If I would have listened and trusted Dr Toth, I could have died. My a1c was above a 14, once treated properly my a1c was a 7. Dr Toth diagnosed me as type 2. I was very sick could hardly keep my eyes open and weighed almost 100 pounds and she blamed it on my diet. I was starting to lose vision and couldn’t stay awake, not even to drive. I finally convince myself … More

Worst practice and horrible doctor! Never around, it takes months to see her and when you do, you spend hours waiting for a 10 min assessment that ends up with you being sent for lab work only to have to wait another several months before you can actually get a dosage for a prescription. Then blood work in a few more months and If that dosage isn’t right repeat steps 1-3 again!!! Mind you that if you miss your appointments you won’t get warned until you’ve passed the limit regardless of the amount of time that has passed or whatever circumstances that may have been. Best thing you can do is find a practice/Dr. that can actually see you and avoid this bombarded and over capacity merry go round. Go to Butler, Pittsburgh or Cleveland. Forget New Castle! She has patients all the way down in Cranberry too... Good luck! Worst practice and horrible doctor! Never around, it takes months to see her and when you do, you spend hours waiting for a 10 min assessment that ends up with you being sent for lab work only to have to wait another several months before … More

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

Very good doctor. Concerned for my well being. Keeps me in line.

Dr. Toth and her nurse were not wearing masks at my appointment. I was very uncomfortable. I follow all the CDC guidelines for Covid 19 protection, and I didn't like the nurse standing over me, taking my blood pressure without a mask. Then leaving me in a small room with the door closed. I only hope they get regular testing. I wore my mask for them and they should return the courtesy.

Where do I begin? Appointment scheduling is ridiculous. They schedule 3 patients all at the same time, in 15 min intervals. On average, expect to be at her office for at least 2.5 hours. Being diabetic, I can't keep my sugar at a normal level for so long without food or insulin. Also, it's a constant battle getting prescription refills. Today was the last straw. I walked out after an hour of not even being acknowledged. I would have waited, if Dr Toth was worth it. She just doesn't care any more. Also, she's like 100 years old, and mean. Maybe it's time to retire already?

Contrary to what I have read on others reviews, I was pleased with the office staff. The only thing I could recommend or change would be when you first enter the office area to register, you are not greeted but are met with a frosted window and your presence is not acknowledged until the nurse calls you back. I would rate Dr. Toth as exceptional in her medical knowledge and patient care. She listens and explains without rushing thru and makes sure you understand everything.

I have seen her in the New Castle office for several years. It is always the same thing a 2 hour wait!! Poor Comunication from her office staff!! They even moved the office once and I wasn't informed!! I feel I paid for an extra appointment where nothing was done except schedule an appointment for an procedure that was delayed because of another medical issue. She still uses paper files which she must dig through to find prior results. A computer system would help. We in the Shenango Valley have little choice. It is go to her or head for Ohio.

I've seen her for the last couple years, and finally stopped going. The wait time is 1.5 hours or longer past your appt time. It can be shorter, depending on the day or time you scheduled. Knowing she likes to take her time with each patient, they really need to be scheduling less people in a day so people aren't waiting forever. Another issue I have is that to get my results, I have to schedule another appointment, wait hours past my appt time, and pay another $60 copay. It's ridiculous. Give me the results over the phone - if I feel like I need more clarification or follow up, then we can schedule an appointment. To me this is a way to get more money and bill my insurance again. As for her as a doctor, she is a warm, caring person. I do believe her intention is to help people. However, she wanted to put me on metformin when I wasn't a diabetic. I told her I preferred to lose weight through exercise / nutrition. She wasn't happy I made that choice for myself w/o the medication.

Dr. Toth is very caring.

Beside manner was horrendously bad... Nasty dirty looks and no explanations. Also claimed risk of death of not put on medication immediately after checking more blood work but then blew it off and said wait till next appointment in 3 weeks.

Very knowledgeable and friendly

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

She’s an excellent physician. I recommend her all the time!!

I would not recommend Dr Toth to anyone unless you have 2 or more hours to wait in the waiting room. I certainly am not questioning the Dr's credibility however the office staff is rude and unprofessional.

I was very pleased with Dr. Toth's expertise and care toward my condition. she spent a lot of time with me and truly cared about my concerns. She answered all my questions and I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a great doctor.

It's suspect how this woman is allowed to continue practicing medicine. Her attitude, staff and even her approach to treatment (even from someone with common, basic knowledge) would be laughable, if it wasn't scary. I'm not exactly sure where she received her training or her credentials, but they clearly need updated. She treats patients the same whether they are 40 and newly diagnosed or in their late 80's. Insulin shouldn't be the first line of defense. You need to find another career path

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

I have now had 2 appointments. I have waited over an hour past my scheduled appointment time for both appointments. I thought maybe it was a bad day the first time, so I gave her the benefit of the doubt. But, 2nd time too. Her office staff are unfriendly and uncaring. Very disappointed.

Has helped me tremendously with my diabetes and some other issues. She also sees my wife and found carotid blockages her dr missed. If you cant be constructive dont comment. To complain about waiting a little is asinine. We find her to be very kind and caring.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

Dr. Toth is a very caring and professional doctor. She was correct in my diagnosis. The doctors at Cleveland Clinic were very impressed at the amount of tests and information they received from Dr. Toth.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

It took over an hour before any of the staff spoke with me during my new patient visit. (not even to fill out paperwork) Dr. Toth was very vocal about her distaste for any insulin pump or CGM than medtronic and seemed unwilling to work with other pump/cgm brands. She would ask questions and did not seem to care for my answers. A1cs are not done in office (requires seperate lab work) and office is cash or check only for copays. Absolutely terrible experience.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

You sit and wait for hrs in the waiting room. Very unorganized and never return calls. Dr toth is very sweet and nice but the office is a mess

Jumped me for daughter's diet. Treating for thyroid not her pcos. No help at all. Wait til apt for blood work results. My dr calls as soon As they get them back. Don't like toth at all. Will not go back or recommend her to anyone!

3 years ago Dr toth detected thyroid cancer on me that other Dr's missed. She helped me with diabetes and now I have a adrenal tumor that she's helping with. I fully trust her.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

They need to have negative numbers because the way she takes care of her patients is..., well that's just it she doesn't !!!!!!!!!! I wouldn't recommend her to my dog, she seems wonderful at first than she totally neglects her patients.. DO NOT GO TO HER!!!!!!

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

I did like Dr Toth, her office staff is horrible, does not call you back. I got charged for appointments I cancelled. Waited up to 3 hours in the waiting room. I gave them the benefit of the doubt in case it was a bad day, after 3 times, this seems to be the norm. I called for test results for cancer, no one ever called me back.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

She is very to get in touch with. She takes time to answer my questions. She also has other providers there that can help you with issues.

Do I even have to give one star..? My family and I patiently waited for 40 minutes after a scheduled appointment--the dr saw people who just walked in... Took her time with these people and took even longer to see us and others patiently waiting in the waiting room... THREE other patients in the waiting room told us you'll be waiting for at least 2 hours, they always take so long. THEN the receptionist wouldnt take a clipboard and said I can't be in 3 places at once, set it down. DONT GOHERE

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review